What Temperature To Cook Grilled Cheese On An Electric Skillet?

Last Updated on May 24th, 2023

We may earn commissions for purchases made through links on our site. Learn more on our about us page.

The recommended method of cooking a grilled cheese sandwich on an electric skillet is low and slow. The exact temperature you should set for your electric skillet is medium heat, around 275 degrees Fahrenheit.

It should only take about 5 to 10 minutes for your grilled cheese sandwich to cook at this temperature, following the typical steps involved when making a grilled cheese.

Cheese in 2 slices of bread - What Temperature To Cook Grilled Cheese On An Electric Skillet?

On What Temperature Should You Grill a Perfect Cheese on an Electric Skillet?

As we mentioned above, the temperature of your electric skillet should be around 275 degrees Fahrenheit, which is about medium heat.

The bread should be golden and toasted for the perfect grilled cheese sandwich, while the cheese is completely melted for the perfect cheese pull or gooey cheese inside.

If the temperature is too high, it could result in burnt bread and possibly burnt cheese. On the other hand, if the temperature is too low, the sandwich will take longer and will not cook through.

Medium heat allows the cheese in the grilled cheese sandwich to melt without burning the bread.


Is There a Too-Low Temperature for Grilling Cheese on an Electric Skillet?

Some recipes say 260 degrees Fahrenheit is a good temperature for cooking a grilled cheese sandwich on an electric skillet.

This is still pretty close to 275 degrees and will allow the right amount of heat to distribute through the sandwich. As a result, the bread will toast, and the cheese will melt perfectly at the same time.

Going below 260 degrees is not recommended because although low and slow is the perfect method for grilled cheese, there is such a thing as too low.

The heat that is too low can prevent the bread from toasting and the cheese from melting, which will prevent you from eating, so don’t go lower than 260 degrees.


What Temperature is Too Hot For Grilling Cheese on an Electric Skillet?

Another recommended temperature for cooking grilled cheese on an electric skillet is 300 degrees Fahrenheit.

It is still close to 275, and it is still medium-level heat. So you will still get an even distribution of heat to toast the bread and evenly melt the cheese at 300 degrees.

Heating your electric skillet higher than 300 degrees Fahrenheit could result in dry or burned bread and burnt cheese, ruining your grilled cheese sandwich. The key to the perfect grilled cheese is proper heat distribution.

It is easy to go wrong when melting cheese and toasting bread at the same time, which is why staying around 260-300 degrees is recommended when making grilled cheese on an electric skillet.


How Can You Perfectly Regulate Temperatures When You’re Cooking Grilled Cheese on an Electric Skillet?

Electric skillets have various settings that can be adjusted when using them for cooking. The skillet also has a thermostat that regulates the temperature during the heating process.

When making your grilled cheese sandwich, you can preheat your electric skillet before placing the sandwich on the heat, giving you more control over how long it is being heated.

Using a timer can also help you to make sure that the grilled cheese sandwich is cooked evenly on both sides to ensure that the cheese has melted through.

Leaving the sandwich on for a measured amount of minutes and preheating the skillet to a set temperature are good ways to regulate the cooking process of your grilled cheese.


Things to Avoid Doing When You’re Cooking Grilled Cheese on an Electric Skillet

There are a few things you should avoid when cooking a grilled cheese on an electric skillet, such as:


  • Making the skillet too hot
  • Not making the skillet hot enough
  • Heating the sandwich without butter


We have already discussed the reasons why you shouldn’t use too-low or too-high heat when toasting your grilled cheese sandwich. Avoid uneven cooking by staying between 260 and 300 degrees.

Another tip is to butter the bread before placing it in the skillet so that the bread cooks at a steady pace and toasts to a perfect golden color rather than burning or becoming dry.


Final Thoughts on What Temperature to Cook Grilled Cheese on an Electric Skillet

Grilled cheese sandwiches are arguably the simplest ones to make, but so many things could go wrong when making them on an electric skillet.

We have given you some tips about what temperatures are best for making your perfect grilled cheese and given some pointers on how to regulate the temperature of the skillet by preheating it.

Remember to butter your bread and stick to 260-300 degrees to get that perfectly toasty, melty grilled cheese sandwich.

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply